On Love Island, not all lovers are also winners.
Photo: Ben Symons/Peacock
All across Love Island–land, there are whispers and murmurs: Bryce and Trinity, current royalty of the villa, are Nicolandria 2.0. (Or Temu Nicolandria, if you prefer.) Bryce, much like season seven’s Nic Vansteenberghe, is a cute white guy with floppy hair and cheekbones; Trinity, like season seven’s Olandria Carthen, is a gorgeous Black woman who distinguishes herself among the other islanders with her down-to-earth directness. They’ve explored other people, which is in the Love Island job description, and they’ve ultimately decided that they do, in fact, love each other. There’s even an easy and memorable ship name for the couple: Brinity, which is alarmingly easy to confuse with the name Britney, but no matter. The phenomenon-in-the-making is so obvious, producers might as well start writing the $100,000 check now.
Ah, but not so fast. It takes more than a superficial physical resemblance and some matching recoupling outfits to crown a new supreme couple of Love Island, and though Brinity seem well on the road to success, they’ve skipped a crucial stage of Nicolandria’s appeal: the slow burn. Many things factored into the Nicolandria phenomenon, but timing was chief among them. They only got together in the show’s last stretch, after weeks of connections with other people, which means Brinity is facing a counterintuitive problem: These two sweet goofballs decided they like each other, so much so that they’ve become boyfriend and girlfriend, but there’s still a week and a half left of this show. What will they do with themselves?
Bryce and Trinity came out of Casa Amor in a power position. They realized that the odd circumstances of the show, which initially required them to couple up out of convenience rather than a strong connection, have resulted in authentic feelings for each other. (Don’t forget Bryce and Zach were initially the fan-favorite relationship.) While everyone else spent Casa Amor exploring new connections, Bryce and Trinity pined for each other, and their post-Casa reunion got a full-blown Snow Patrol–scored set piece with Bryce running (er, awkwardly loping) to her across the villa’s bright-green fake grass. Four episodes later, they’ve become the old married couple of the villa, the mature and settled pair everyone else points to in order to say, “I hope one day we can be like that.” They’ve all but won!
Last night’s Movie Night demonstrates the issue Bryce and Trinity now face: This isn’t about them anymore. Before the footage even started rolling, the major point of tension was Kenzie’s conversation with Dylan, when he began weeping after learning she was kissing Gal. Once Movie Night started, the clips picked at the current drama surrounding KC choosing Tierra over Aniya and the lack of trust between Kayda and Zach and dragged up new angles of fights that seemed long settled, like Sincere’s decision to pursue Sol while reassuring Melanie about the strength of their relationship. There were no clips relating to Trinity and Bryce; their story was sidelined entirely in favor of examining the churn among their fellow islanders.
That’s great news for Brinity as a couple, but it creates a real challenge for Bryce and Trinity as two people vying for to win this season of television. Much can happen in the next eight episodes, and without internal fissures, the couple will need some external event to shake things up between them in order to keep tension brewing as they head into the final stretch. Getting distracted by a late-stage bombshell would feel disingenuous at this point. There may be some juice in Bryce defending KC while Trinity stands up for Aniya, but that also seems easy to overcome. Unless they can finagle a short but believable third-act breakup, Bryce and Trinity lack friction. The show will provide them with some busywork over the next several episodes, including taking a probable trip to the hideaway and meeting each other’s families, but that route leads to a light and fun rom-com plot for Brinity, and even good rom-coms still hold on to some suspense to give the final story beats enough oomph.
Retaining a little bit of pressure is crucial — attention is currency, and there’s enormous pleasure in rooting for a couple that makes it work despite the odds. If, somehow, Melanie and Sincere sort out their nonsense and Sincere has a persuasive epiphany about what a jerk he’s been, that pairing could gather some feel-good third-act momentum and end up with a Kordell-and-Serena-style story line, culminating in a big reveal where everyone has it all out and comes to a deeper understanding. (Yes, this would require Sincere to engage in legitimate self-reflection and Melanie to pull herself together, and both of those things feel highly implausible. But that’s why it would be such appealing television!) But there’s also Carl and Aniya, the newly minted Caniya. They’re a potentially more exciting alternative to the Bryce-and-Trinity victory sweep, especially if there’s a scenario where some brief blip allows Carl to distance himself from Aniya so they can have a glorious reunion right as the show is about to end.
There’s one final aspect to the Brinity relationship that sounds a note of concern. The key element of Nicolandria’s rise in the last few weeks of season seven was the impression that the fandom could see signs that the two islanders had not yet seen in each other. Nic and Olandria were sweet as friends, but watching the conversations on social media, it felt as if the fandom was trying to pair them up like a kid mashing two dolls’ faces together. The producers essentially did as much once both were exiled from Casa Amor, and the two made the mutual decision to couple up onscreen. Brinity, conversely, has figured out their attraction all on their own — and good for them! That may work in their favor, especially because despite their fan-favorite stance, Nicolandria did not actually win the show. Love Island is a viewer-participatory show, and by coupling up so quickly, Brinity has left nothing for viewers to either root for or fuck with. That may be a good road to building a relationship, but historically, that is not the route to Love Island success.
Sign up for the Vulture Daily
An entertainment newsletter for the pop-culture obsessed.
Vox Media, LLC Terms and Privacy Notice
See All