Is Lost in Paradise Lacey Chabert’s Best Hallmark Movie Ever? Full Review
Hallmark January movies are usually where joy goes to die, but Lost in Paradise (aka Love in Paradise) just changed the game. Hallmark stranded Lacey Chabert and Ian Harding on a tropical island in Fiji, and somehow, it resulted in the best banter I’ve heard in years!
In this review, we’re breaking down why this is Hallmark’s perfect apology for years of disappointing January releases (looking at you, Love on the Right Course). We discuss the undeniable chemistry between Lacey and Ian, the surprisingly smart character writing for Sofia, and the most ridiculous “survival” details that I just couldn’t stop laughing at.
From the “Hallmark-style” plane crash to the pristine island fashion, find out why this movie is the perfect escape—and why we need Ian Harding in every Hallmark movie from now on.
👇 Don’t miss out on the new merch! Grab your “Real Men Watch Hallmark Movies” gear and more at the official shop: https://hallmarkmysteriesandmore.com Use code JAN26 for 15% off your order!
🎥 Watch Next: Why A Dog Named Christmas is the best Hallmark dog movie ever: https://youtu.be/v4ewBbSVIYI?si=AGn21beL7DDstQWs
In this video:
Movie: Lost in Paradise (2025)
Stars: Lacey Chabert & Ian Harding
Setting: Fiji (and a very clean deserted island)
Verdict: A must-watch for banter lovers!
Video Chapters
0:00 Intro: Did Hallmark Fix January?
1:12 The Setting: Fiji & The Escape
2:08 Lacey & Ian: Chemistry Masterclass
2:51 Why Sofia Actually Works (Unlike Ella!)
4:24 The Ian Harding Factor
5:00 The Most “Hallmark” Plane Crash Ever
6:02 The Pilot: James Trevena
7:38 Island Fashion: Survival Chic
8:12 The Ridiculous Detail I Can’t Ignore
9:02 Giovanni the Dog (MVP!)
10:08 Flash Forwards & Final Verdict
10:55 Merch Drop & Outro
35 Comments
Team snow ❄️
For me its sweet carolina. My favorite by far!
The Wedding Veil.
Okay… I said it. Is Lost in Paradise Lacey Chabert’s BEST Hallmark movie ever? 👀
Drop your vote: YES / NO / “It’s __ instead”
And if you’re saying “no,” tell me what is her #1: Christmas in Rome? All of My Heart? Haul Out the Holly?
Want to rep the fandom? Remember to use promo code JAN26 for 15% of your order. Merch shop: https://hallmarkmysteriesandmore.com
12 bucks and a Groupon 😂
Sorry I can't agree. The movie was lousy – why was she always carrying (actually struggling to carry) that dog?
Very cute! I liked the one where she was in Vail too= even though Streudelfest is pretty out there.
I absolutely loved this movie!❤ It was definitely my favorite Lacey movie. The quick back and forth banter between the two of them just showed what great actors they both are. My only criticism was when they were running from the pirates, I kept yelling "where is the dog!"
I enjoyed this movie. Loved how the pirates were part of the hotel staff. Very clever.
This was totally the best Hallmark movie this season. The chemistry was perfect and just right. Hallmark should do a series with them of an updated old classic Thin Man or something along those lines. Think it would be a hit.
This movie is definitely a winner and thanks for reminding me of Elevator Girl My recent Lacey movie is She's Making A List because of the breaking of the fourth wall When that happens in a movie it gabs my attention.
Loved it! I had to do a double take because I thought his friend was Chris Hemsworth…lol.
lol I somehow liked winter castle
Agree on Ian. He was great. Why isn’t he in more hallmark movies?
I loved the movie!
I loved Elevator Girl and that’s Lacey’s first Hallmark movie. I’d loved , loved Lost in Paradise that I DVR it cause I don’t have hallmark+ and my daughter wanted to watch it. I’m glad there wasn’t a particular Hallmark part the person didn’t hear the half truth. Thank you so much and I love your opinions and blessings.
Loved this movie! Really love Ian.
The following week's movie was also a winner
Lacey Chabert basically plays Lacey Chabert in every movie. She isn't a bad actress, but IMHO, she is a very boring actress.
Ian Harding was excellent.
Thanks for the review, I had initially passed. Not the best. Love Romance & Chololate or Christmas Waltz.
Yeah, the Pirates (spoiler rescuers) was awkward and unnecessary.
I liked the movie. The Christmas movie that Lacey was in, Time for Us to Come Home For Christmas, was well done.
I love Lacey and I loved this movie. Is it her best? Hard to say, because she's made so many of my all-time favorites like All of My Heart, Christmas Waltz, Haul Out the Holly, Winter in Vail and She's Making a List
We need more Ian Harding in Hallmark movies!💌
Winter in Vail and Time for us to come home are my favorite Lacey movies.
I liked it. I am a 77 y.o. cynical romantic…a contradiction in terms, I suppose.
I love love love Ian Harding! He’s the only reason I watched this. I do prefer snow over tropical any day, but he’s so damn charming and amazing! I enjoyed this movie far more than I thought I would! I agree with you that I want to see more of James Trevena. I’ve been calling him the Hallmark Hemsworth 😂. He would be great in a lead role! And believe it or not, my favorite Lacey Chabert movie is elevator girl, though honestly I love it more for Ryan Merriman ♥️
I was definitely ready to get out of the snow into the gorgeous island and sunny sea. I’m happy also that there wasn’t the usual tension and blaming game going on. But it’s Hallmark, so I had the sneaky suspicion this was a private island of some sort, or at least with a fancy hotel on the other side of the island… but isn’t there always. I watch anything with Lacey in it.
We were very disappointed. The actors were OK, but really: A White blouse and sequin skirt look no worse for wear after a plane crash? Clothes not damaged in the water? Laughable…not in an entertaining way. I wondered why Lacey would have accepted this approach.
It was ok but wouldn't watch it again.
I loved the movie! The script had some really good lines and the actors played them well!
loved this movie
I really didn’t like this movie. I thought the story was ridiculous. I really loved Love on the Right Course. That’s the power of Hallmark movies. Something for every taste.
Can we mention how hilarious the side characters were. I couldn't stop laughin when they were out at sea in a storm on that little raft! Yes, bring the pilot back, he's too much hemsworth-ish fun not to!
Favorite Lacey movies is It is Time for Us to Come Home for Christmas