Is this an Alan Moore situation? He hates everything.
The OG Watchmen movie was legitimately good. 🤷♂️
imikonicbaby on
Apparently this book is heavily about colourism and the actress cast for a dark skinned role is light skinned. Might have been one of the factors contributing to this.
BadAspie on
First time I ever heard about her was when she accused Nora Roberts of stealing her title because Nora happened to publish *Of Blood and Bone* at around the same time
Was that a weird one-off, or has there been some good drama that I’ve missed since then?
Equalanimalfarm on
A few things:
– This is how important it is to make sure you have a say, as an author, in who is cast when that is essential to the story (not blaming the author, just wonder what went wrong when she sold the story to be adapted into film, was she ill advised? Dus she approve and then change her mind?)
– Don’t blame the actor for decisions that were made by the producer, sounds like they could have been more considerate and careful with the source material. I seriously wonder what went down when they decided to adapt this book, that clearly has a lot of parallels with our world that are at the heart of the story and then decide to ignore that (according to the critics online of course, I can’t find what the casting process entailed)
– It feels very very wrong that Amandla Stenberg is suddenly at the center of this controversy. As stated, she has experienced a lot of racism since the beginning of her carreer and now she is being chastised for this, while she has previously explained what her process was of auditioning for this role: https://www.complex.com/pop-culture/a/jaelaniturnerwilliams/amandla-stenberg-on-painful-children-of-blood-and-bone-colorism-allegations
sparklinglies on
I am DYING to know what the hell happened between her and Amandla Stenberg. How did they go from Tomi wanting and defending Amandla’s casting (even though Tomi should have known from Day 1 it wasn’t right) to her telling Amandla to never call, text or even mention her name again.
Illustrious_Force937 on
Curious about what happened with Amandla Sternberg that caused Tomi to block her. if I remember correctly Amandla made a tiktok stating that Toni wanted her in the role…
I also find it odd that Tomi would distance herself after co writing the script and her heavy involvement with the film’s production. Didn’t she say her separation from Disney/Lucas Film was because of them refusing to let her co write?
Either way, it feels like paramount is setting up the film for failure with that January 15th release date.
this_sminks on
Dang, I was looking forward to this because I genuinely love the book and was excited to see the adaptation. I think I’ll look into this a little more and read a few sources and decide if I wanna see it or pretend it’s a fever dream. I loved how into the whole experience the author was during the process of making this and now I’m kinda bummed.
Artistic-Lock1021 on
I don’t love that she threw another woman under the bus publicly here. She’s allowed to feel how she feels about the casting but she must know that this will implicitly give permission to weirdos who want to bombard that actress with abuse.
Cozyinfrance on
Why didn’t she negociate in her contact to have say in the main character casting? Colourism is a very real problem that should be solved by changing things on paper and not demanding black women police each other. Where is all the rage against production? Why is Amandla being vilainized and shamed ? Is a lot easier to blame minorities I guess 🤷🏽♀️
AngelicalBabe3 on
It’s disappointing when discussions about adaptation choices turn into personal attacks on actors instead of focusing on the people who approved those choices.
No_Win_4088 on
Good authority
Many-Birthday12345 on
After the Eragon and Lightning thief fiascos, I tend to take the author’s side in these things initially.
Hollywood has been known to ignore dark skinned black women in favor of lighter/biracial-looking ones. “The author herself wants this specific actress” could have been a narrative enforced on the Adeyemi and everyone else for damage control.
_NightBitch_ on
I’m confused. Amandla is supposed to play Amari, right? That’s the character the author originally wanted Zendaya or Tessa Thompson to play. Why is Amandla suddenly a problem?
JustDay1788 on
Anyone working in Hollywood knows you dont talk about in house business outside
this makes her seem like a mean girl
she publicly defended Amandla’s casting before
and then sends her a text telling her never to mention her and then blocks her
If I am a studio exec , this would soar me off adapting the rest of her books or working with her since she co wrote the script
she is deliberartely undermining the future of the project and millions attached to that project by fueling a public scandal which had already somewhat subsided
people who saw a clip of the movie at Cinemacon said it looked amazing
Amandla isnt a unknown actress , she knew what she looked like when she was cast
supported and defended the casting publicly
and now wants to be a victim
all she had to say is Im not allowed to say anything about the film yet
Ive also seen a few readers complain the Children of Blood and Bone books
get worse as they go along and arent really original either
so the delusion she is a great writer has worn off with a lot of them
she also hasnt even seem the film yet so this comes across like diva behavior of a child who didnt get all her demands met and is ungrateful
if it sucks she could chyme in them
if it ends up being good she will be seen as a problem
she needs to take a playbook from Sue Nyathis the author of the Polygamist
super quiet until the show comes out and hits and she is suddenly everywhere promoting her books
If the film adaptation sucks she co wrote the script so she has blame in that
Ambitious-Chest2061 on
Who reads the book and auditions for it as a light skin??? Once you have money, you don’t gaf about other interests
17 Comments
TIL they’re still making YA adaptations.
But she will collect the paycheck
Is this an Alan Moore situation? He hates everything.
The OG Watchmen movie was legitimately good. 🤷♂️
Apparently this book is heavily about colourism and the actress cast for a dark skinned role is light skinned. Might have been one of the factors contributing to this.
First time I ever heard about her was when she accused Nora Roberts of stealing her title because Nora happened to publish *Of Blood and Bone* at around the same time
Was that a weird one-off, or has there been some good drama that I’ve missed since then?
A few things:
– This is how important it is to make sure you have a say, as an author, in who is cast when that is essential to the story (not blaming the author, just wonder what went wrong when she sold the story to be adapted into film, was she ill advised? Dus she approve and then change her mind?)
– Don’t blame the actor for decisions that were made by the producer, sounds like they could have been more considerate and careful with the source material. I seriously wonder what went down when they decided to adapt this book, that clearly has a lot of parallels with our world that are at the heart of the story and then decide to ignore that (according to the critics online of course, I can’t find what the casting process entailed)
– It feels very very wrong that Amandla Stenberg is suddenly at the center of this controversy. As stated, she has experienced a lot of racism since the beginning of her carreer and now she is being chastised for this, while she has previously explained what her process was of auditioning for this role:
https://www.complex.com/pop-culture/a/jaelaniturnerwilliams/amandla-stenberg-on-painful-children-of-blood-and-bone-colorism-allegations
I am DYING to know what the hell happened between her and Amandla Stenberg. How did they go from Tomi wanting and defending Amandla’s casting (even though Tomi should have known from Day 1 it wasn’t right) to her telling Amandla to never call, text or even mention her name again.
Curious about what happened with Amandla Sternberg that caused Tomi to block her. if I remember correctly Amandla made a tiktok stating that Toni wanted her in the role…
I also find it odd that Tomi would distance herself after co writing the script and her heavy involvement with the film’s production. Didn’t she say her separation from Disney/Lucas Film was because of them refusing to let her co write?
Either way, it feels like paramount is setting up the film for failure with that January 15th release date.
Dang, I was looking forward to this because I genuinely love the book and was excited to see the adaptation. I think I’ll look into this a little more and read a few sources and decide if I wanna see it or pretend it’s a fever dream. I loved how into the whole experience the author was during the process of making this and now I’m kinda bummed.
I don’t love that she threw another woman under the bus publicly here. She’s allowed to feel how she feels about the casting but she must know that this will implicitly give permission to weirdos who want to bombard that actress with abuse.
Why didn’t she negociate in her contact to have say in the main character casting? Colourism is a very real problem that should be solved by changing things on paper and not demanding black women police each other. Where is all the rage against production? Why is Amandla being vilainized and shamed ? Is a lot easier to blame minorities I guess 🤷🏽♀️
It’s disappointing when discussions about adaptation choices turn into personal attacks on actors instead of focusing on the people who approved those choices.
Good authority
After the Eragon and Lightning thief fiascos, I tend to take the author’s side in these things initially.
Hollywood has been known to ignore dark skinned black women in favor of lighter/biracial-looking ones. “The author herself wants this specific actress” could have been a narrative enforced on the Adeyemi and everyone else for damage control.
I’m confused. Amandla is supposed to play Amari, right? That’s the character the author originally wanted Zendaya or Tessa Thompson to play. Why is Amandla suddenly a problem?
Anyone working in Hollywood knows you dont talk about in house business outside
this makes her seem like a mean girl
she publicly defended Amandla’s casting before
and then sends her a text telling her never to mention her and then blocks her
If I am a studio exec , this would soar me off adapting the rest of her books or working with her since she co wrote the script
she is deliberartely undermining the future of the project and millions attached to that project by fueling a public scandal which had already somewhat subsided
people who saw a clip of the movie at Cinemacon said it looked amazing
Amandla isnt a unknown actress , she knew what she looked like when she was cast
supported and defended the casting publicly
and now wants to be a victim
all she had to say is Im not allowed to say anything about the film yet
Ive also seen a few readers complain the Children of Blood and Bone books
get worse as they go along and arent really original either
so the delusion she is a great writer has worn off with a lot of them
she also hasnt even seem the film yet so this comes across like diva behavior of a child who didnt get all her demands met and is ungrateful
if it sucks she could chyme in them
if it ends up being good she will be seen as a problem
she needs to take a playbook from Sue Nyathis the author of the Polygamist
super quiet until the show comes out and hits and she is suddenly everywhere promoting her books
If the film adaptation sucks she co wrote the script so she has blame in that
Who reads the book and auditions for it as a light skin??? Once you have money, you don’t gaf about other interests